With the recent excitement and disruption caused by baby Leon I have not had time to write in my blog about my latest toy… yes, I finally (a few weeks ago) acquired a PSP.
The PSP is running firmware 3.03OE-B which, anybody who knows anything about PSPs, will know means it is capable of running homebrew and backups of games (note I say backups as obviously I am not going to condone piracy here!). The PSP I acquired also came with the original UMD of Burnout Legends and a 1GB memory stick. Unfortunately though, after a couple of weeks use I managed to corrupt the memory stick. Luckily I think I know what I did wrong so hopefully will not make the same mistake twice however the 1GB memory stick does seem to be screwed… neither the PSP nor a card reader on my PC can read or format the card
ANYWAY! What do you do? Well… you go buy a new 4GB memory stick instead! This arrived today and, as I type this post, I am transferring a few bits and pieces to it via the USB cable and all seems to be working very well.
So, having now played the PSP and the Nintendo DS the question is… which is better? Well, I think the answer is inconclusive, both systems seem to have their strengths and weaknesses. For those who are considering buying either a Nintendo DS or a PSP, here are my thoughts which may be of some help to you:-
Price
This has always been one of the big critisms of the PSP and yes, the unit itself is more expensive however, if you are using a PSP or DS for homebrew consider the fact that, for the DS, you will need to buy a special flash card such as an R4 whilst for the PSP, if you feel comfortable in hacking and flashing your PSP yourself, you will not need to incur any additional costs on the hardware side. This of course excludes perhaps your need for a larger capacity memory stick for the PSP however, if you buy a flash card for the DS you will most likely need to buy a similar memory card for that unit too.
However, as memory sticks for the PSP are more expensive than memory cards for a DS flash card it is likely that overall the PSP will be the more expensive system hence, whether you buy a PSP over the DS will be dependent on other factors…
The Games
In this regard the DS probably currently has the edge in innovation thanks to it’s dual screen/touch screen set up. However, if you prefer pure power and graphics over innovation then the PSP kicks butt. Therefore, if you are after a portable system capable of displaying PS2/Xbox graphics and you play a lot of 3D/Racing games then the PSP is for you. However, if you prefer to enjoy some of the addictive playability that Nintendo has to offer in the likes of Super Mario Bros or Yoshi’s Island then the DS is the way to go. The touch screen is also a unique feature that allows the DS to do games that just would not work on the PSP. An example being the recently released Dead’N Furious which, is a House of the Dead type clone whereby you use the stylus to touch the screen to simulate your shooting.
If you are looking to fill your flash card or memory stick with backup games then bear in mind that the PSP games, being graphically so much more intensive, also are significantly larger in size thus, unless you get a large memory stick for your PSP, the number of games you can likely carry around on your memory stick will be less than the number of games you are likely to have sitting on the memory card of your DS.
The Homebrew
Both systems have a strong community of homebrew software with both systems having several highlights.
On the DS, you may have noted from previous posts, that I have been very impressed with the port of Doom and the ZX Spectrum emulator. The latter works extremely well due to its identical resolution to the original ZX Spectrum whilst the Doom port works very well thanks to the clever use of the second screen showing the map.
There is a Doom port for the PSP but to be honest, although the PSP has more power and can run it more smoothly, the lack of the second map screen gave the DS version the edge. However, that is not to say the PSP does not outclass the DS in other areas of homebrew. For example, staying with the Doom theme, the PSP has an excellent port of Quake which, quite frankly, the DS does not have the processing power to match. In addition, thanks to the additional power of the PSP, it is also capable of emulation of systems such as the SNES which again the DS struggles to emulate.
Multimedia
Thanks to homebrew the DS is capable of playing MP3s and video but, having briefly tried these abilities suggest you are best keeping your DS as a games machine.
The PSP on the other hand is well capable of playing video and MP3s. I personally don’t think the external speakers of the PSP are that great but, plug in a set of headphones and the PSP sound is dramatically improved. I personally haven’t listened to much music by the PSP yet but I have watched a few episodes of Lost on the PSP which I thorougly enjoyed as I could watch them in bed whilst my wife was breastfeeding the baby.
Durability
This is perhaps just a personal opinion but the Nintendo DS feels stronger to me. Not that I suggest you drop your console to test such things but I just feel the Nintendo DS can be handled more comfortably whilst the PSP, particularly because of it’s beautiful widescreen display and the fact that it doesn’t have an effective cover over the screen (unlike the fold away style of the DS) feels a lot more delicate to me.
For my PSP I have purchased a hard shell logitech case and I really would strongly recommend anyone who buys a PSP to also invest in a strong protective shell asap.
It should perhaps also be noted that, touch wood, I have never had any issues with the DS flash card whilst, as I noted at the start, I have successfully managed to destroy a 1GB memory stick for the PSP with little effort. Although I realise now how I might have caused this corruption I think this fault occurred too easily and has made me very weary of what I do with the new 4GB stick.
And the winner is…
Well, as I hinted at the start of this post, I don’t think there is an outright winner.
Both systems have their pros and cons. Personally I love the DS and the PSP and, I have to say I even equally love the Gameboy Micro which, although uncompetitive now in the fact that its games are last generation, still has some pros of its own that cannot be matched by the DS or PSP.
So what should you do… well… don’t be tight, buy a DS, a PSP and a Gameboy Micro! Ok, so maybe that isn’t really helpful advice… I guess the bottom line is, you need to look at all the handhelds available and make a decision based on what you expect to get out of the console. They all have their place so, my little handheld buddies… I hope you all live long and prosper!